Previous Entry | Next Entry

Stargate book club

  • Jun. 11th, 2008 at 12:27 PM
pepper: Pepperpot (Default)
Much yayness for Do No Harm. Admittedly I'm only on page 54, but it is very... grown-up and thinky and interesting, so far. Plus Janet called Jack the cuddly mascot of the Tough Love Club, and there's a very interesting back-story for Dave Dixon (was he really only in Heroes? I could've sworn he was in more eps). Good stuff.

Whilst I'm on the subject of Stargate books...

More backstory in Siren Song - that's what I love about the books. Interesting stuff about Aris Boch, although... maybe it's just me, but I felt that they made him too clearly one of the Good Guys. I liked his ambiguity in Deadman's Switch, never really knowing what his true history was - kind of like Vala. And I was slightly dubious about the plot - Ancients can't destroy this monster, but they can lock it in a mountain and engineer people to guard it? I swear I'm not trying to be contrary, [personal profile] orca_girl! :) I did enjoy the journey, however, and I liked the uncertainty of the ending. Perhaps it's just that my expectations were too high. 

On the other hand, I really didn't have high expectations for Trial By Fire... and really enjoyed it. :) I'm totally in the minority here, I know - but aside from a few niggles (did they have to make it clear, with every single line she spoke, that OFC was British? Ye gods. No one speaks like that. But when they relaxed with that a bit, it was better), it was entertaining, completely undemanding, and had some fun running around in costumes. Plus, it gave me the great mental image of Jack naked and covered in honey. Little things please little minds. *g* I read it when I was coming down with a cold, and it helped me survive a couple of endless journeys home from work.

---

More about Do No Harm when, er, I've actually finished reading it. 

Comments

pepper: Pepperpot (Yay)
[personal profile] pepper wrote:
May. 3rd, 2010 04:27 pm (UTC)
Hoorah! Yes to your points about the OFC (who I would happily have throttled for about the first third of the book), and yeah, it follows the Stargate tradition of Obviously Evil Aliens That Our Heroes Think Are Good. But Jack and Daniel got to work out some Abyss issues, Jack coped on his own with the wacky alien culture, and the others worked things out from the other end (and Sam had a great little "I am woman, hear me roar!" bit). I loved Jack's worry that, oh god, please don't let that have been Carter's plan that killed all those people.

I'm just sad that they passed up an opportunity to have Jack naked and covered in honey. *g*
holdouttrout: not your ordinary fish (Default)
[personal profile] holdouttrout wrote:
May. 3rd, 2010 05:32 pm (UTC)
Yes. Despite the OFC of annoying doomosity, the book was surprisingly Stargate-y. I liked the work-through of Abyss issues, and I liked the whole rockslide bit and Jack's reaction to it--and Sam's reaction to that reaction. :-)

Having Jack naked and covered in honey tree sap is your area of expertise... and more fun when it doesn't have to be canon-compliant. :-D

Latest Month

November 2023
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  

Page Summary

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Designed by [personal profile] chasethestars